Stop Going Against Your Gut

 

You know what’s right, but you don’t trust it.

There’s a part of you that senses you should fold the river after a bad card hits, but you convince yourself to call anyway.

You know you should wait a little longer before entering a trade, but price action is moving fast and you quickly fire off a trade.

You have a feeling that you should take less club with an approach shot from a tight lie in the fairway, but the yardage says you should take more and you choose the “logical” club instead.

The rationale is correct on paper. Yet when your intuition wants to deviate and the results back it up, you know your gut was right, yet again. ARGGGGG!!! It’s so frustrating to have the correct answer and not be able to capitalize on it. 

And then it can be hard not to get pissed off and blame yourself for going against, ignoring, or talking yourself out of what you knew was right. 

Let’s commit to making this experience a thing of the past. By understanding a bit more about intuition, since MANY of you have it wrong, and doing a little bit of work to learn how to make use of it, you can dramatically reduce how often you go against it.

I’m not saying your gut is always right, but going against it ensures that your process is worse, even if the outcome works out.

Honestly, it makes sense why trusting your gut can be tricky. It’s not part of your normal process, there’s no thinking involved, and the answer seems to come out of nowhere. No wonder it often feels foreign and wrong. Like trusting a stranger with your baby.

Plus, there are plenty of times when emotions seduce you into believing your creative idea, aggressive action, or protective instinct comes from that genuine intuitive place…but, alas, it was overconfidence, anger, or fear and instead you repeat the same tired mistake.

The urge to put on more risk, swing harder with the driver, or bomb the river with a marginal hand can feel like a sixth sense when it’s overconfidence.

Fear pulls the same trick in reverse. Staying out of a trade, folding a medium-strength hand, playing it safe off the tee – all of that can feel prudent when it’s really anxiety driving you toward a decision you’ll regret.

Mistrust of any decisions not made with sound logic and reason undermines your ability to trust the authenticity of your intuition. This is especially problematic because intuition is based upon knowledge that is so new, you can’t explain it yet.

How then can you trust something you can’t explain? By understanding what makes it reliable and identifying the markers that distinguish intuition from emotion masquerading as it.

Intuition is the mental equivalent of the incredible adjustments or reactions athletes display when they go beyond training and do something they’ve never done before. Like Saquon Barkley reverse hurdling a defender.

Incredible. And when asked to explain it, he said his “body just took over.”

And that’s the thing about intuition in trading, poker, and golf, it relies on a depth of knowledge, experience, skill and pattern recognition. Intuition doesn’t come out of nowhere. 

As a coach, my intuitive abilities are perhaps best seen in how quickly I can now assess the cause of a new client’s issues. What took me four to six sessions when I first started, I can now do in just minutes because my senses have become so well sharpened and trained.

This reminds me of a story Malcom Gladwell cited in his book, Blink: The Power of Thinking Without Thinking. He described a famous instance where a museum spent more than a year testing an ancient statue using scientific and chemical methods, which all verified authenticity. Yet, when two art historians saw the statue in person, they both instantly knew it was a fake.

How? It’s not as if the forgery was obvious to a general observer. On the contrary, the culmination of all of their training and experience produced an immediate reaction but it was hard to explain what was wrong.

That’s why newer traders, poker players and golfers, should be skeptical of the reliability of their intuition – if it even gets produced at all. They’re lacking the foundation of skills.

Before I give you a few ideas on how to trust your intuition more, we also need to separate it from instinct. The two terms are often used interchangeably when they’re very different.

Instinct is based upon knowledge that is so well ingrained, or mastered, automatic decisions come naturally and instantaneously, but they’re repetitive in nature. Instinct is standard. There’s nothing new, other than perhaps being applied in a novel situation.

Intuition, on the other hand, is pure innovation. While it may also come instantly and naturally, like instinct, you’ve produced something entirely new. Think of intuition as the front end of your inchworm taking a step forward, while instinct comes from the back end.

 

Cultivating Intuition

These days, a lot of us lean on outside tools to get better like coaching, trading groups, YouTube, or AI-generated summaries of mental game material. Some are genuinely useful. But there’s no substitute for developing your own sense of what’s right, whether that’s reading your opponent, the market, or a lie in the fairway. 

Cultivate intuition and you’ll have an endless source of organic growth.

How can you do that when intuition itself can be hard to put into words? Let’s start by zeroing in on the times it happens since you won’t always hear the word “intuition” mentioned out loud. In golf, for instance, players will talk about having “a feel for how the hole is playing.” Traders and poker players mention having a “discretionary style” or “playing exploitatively.”

These are all ways to describe the adaptations that come to you rather than being solely derived from top-down, logical and analytical processes. This is not to say that relying on intuition is superior to logic for everyone. We all have our own unique competitive fingerprint and you will perform best when you are most aligned with yours.

If you’re more logical, and intuition doesn’t arise for you as reliably, that’s fine. If you’re more emotional and intuitive that’s great too, though you need to take steps to ensure your emotions aren’t contaminating the environment from which intuition arises. 

For me, there are many times when I’m working with a client and something feels off about what they are saying. My spidey sense might be tingling, but I don’t always immediately know what’s off or how to figure it out. I allow my intuition to guide me, while bringing some logic into the equation. I ask questions, bounce ideas off the client, and collectively we figure it out and create some of the most consequential break-throughs.

In client work I have the luxury of a collaborative interaction. Those aren’t the conditions when I’m competing. In golf, bringing logic and analysis to make sense of my intuition before hitting a shot dulls my athleticism and the value of that intuition is gone. Years of experience and practice has taught me when to trust my gut.

Figure out what works best for you. Intuition is fragile and needs the right conditions to arise. Imagine if those art historians hadn’t slept, or were jacked up on caffeine before examining the statue, would they’ve had the same reaction? Or, been able to trust their senses as easily?

If you want to get better at producing reliable intuition that will help you improve your performance, start here:

  1. Once you have enough experience for intuition to have reasonable reliability, take a piece of paper and draw a vertical line down the middle.
  2. On one side write distinguishing characteristics of intuition. For example, the quality of your thinking, energy level, focus, decision-making process, physical state, and emotions. The on the other side, do the same thing for instance where emotions, like overconfidence or fear, seem to produce intuition when actually they’re repetitive mistakes.
  3. Repeat with new situations so you can sharpen your eye to quickly distinguish intuition in real-time.

 

You might find that intuition arises from a calm, poised state of mind, whereas shallow breathing, tension, or clenched fists would be markers of emotion. Once you can immediately qualify or disqualify the reaction as intuition, it becomes easier to trust yourself.

Intuition often comes when you’re in the zone. If you want to dive deeper on this topic, check out The Mental Game of Poker 2. While it’s written in poker language, this book goes deep into topics like, The Zone, Learning, Focus, and Decision-Making, making it easy to sharpen your performance and avoid going against your gut, regardless of your field.

You can also pick up my free e-book, Leveraging Intuition, and start there.  

Either way, once you are more comfortable relying on your gut, it becomes one of the most powerful tools you have to improve performance.

 

If you’d like my blog delivered right to your inbox, click here to be added to the list. 

 

Written by Jared Tendler

October 12, 2026

Recent posts

Answers Are Out There

Answers Are Out There

  Five years ago, along with several industry partners, I surveyed traders from around the world to understand...

Trading Industry Research

Trading Industry Research

I'm partnering with several well-respected trading entities to launch an industry-wide survey. The goal is to clarify...